Pale oak and limestone kitchen in a refined North Shore home, with soft November light and private garden views.

How Winnetka's Biggest Home Sales Happened in 2026

November 19, 2026

In early 2025, the 1926 Mayo & Mayo Tudor at 140 Sheridan Road was listed at around $10 million. The price was later cut to $8.7 million, and the house sold this year for $7.8 million, according to The Real Deal. In February, a 1916 stucco Colonial at 674 Hill Road had an asking price of $4.25 million and sold for $5.6 million, 32 percent over ask, before it ever reached the public market, The Real Deal reported.

The Hill Road result is the more typical one this year. Among the Winnetka sales above $5 million that made the press in 2026, the Tudor is the only one that went through a long public listing. The other four were settled privately, and the private sales held or beat their prices. Buyers paid the most per square foot for newer, finished houses on half-acre lots, and paid much less per square foot for the biggest, oldest estates.

Five Sales Above $5 Million in 2026

Address How it sold Price Reported House Approx. price per sq ft Earlier purchase
715 Sheridan Road Off-market $8.85M to $8.9M Closed Oct. 1 Built 2000, about 6,670 sq ft, 0.82 acre, lakefront access About $1,330 Site bought for $2.9M in June 2000
140 Sheridan Road Public listing, two price cuts $7.8M June Built 1926, 13,171 sq ft, 1.04 acres About $592 $3.05M at a 2023 foreclosure auction
2016 corner-lot house Off-market $6.8M September Built 2016, about 6,100 sq ft, half-acre corner lot About $1,115 Site bought for just under $1.29M in 2013
674 Hill Road Before public marketing, 32% over ask $5.6M February Built 1916 and expanded, 9,000 sq ft, 1 acre About $622 $1.5M in 2014
1096 Laurel Avenue "Off-off-market" $5.5M Late April Built 2015, nearly 6,000 sq ft, half acre $923 Lot and prior house for $1.2M in 2013

I calculated the per-square-foot figures from the reported prices and square footages, except for Laurel Avenue, where The Real Deal published $923. The Hill Road price also included the furniture. Even allowing for that, the gap is wide. The two largest houses on the list, at 13,171 and 9,000 square feet, sold for roughly $600 a foot. The three houses built since 2000, each between about 6,000 and 6,700 square feet, sold for $923 to roughly $1,330.

Buyers Paid Extra for Houses That Were Finished

The buyers' agent on the Hill Road sale told The Real Deal that the price came from a "nearly nonexistent supply" of move-in-ready homes in Winnetka, and that "the market will pay up" for "beautiful, well-furnished homes that you just had to put a key into." That house was built in 1916. It had since been expanded and updated with designs by Morgante-Wilson Architects and James Thomas Interiors, so the buyers got an old Winnetka address with a house that needed nothing.

The 2016 corner-lot house fits the same pattern. It is a finished two-story brick and limestone custom home on a half-acre lot, and it sold off-market for $6.8 million, Chicago Star Media reported in September. The house at 1096 Laurel Avenue in Hubbard Woods, designed by Timm Martin in 2015, came with a finished basement and attic, an indoor sport court and a pool. The Real Deal reported that it sold before it was marketed through either private or public channels.

The 140 Sheridan Tudor was also finished, and finished well. Its owners added a third floor where the attic had been, put in a pool, and kept the original Mayo & Mayo design. What separated it from the others was size and a publicly posted price. At 13,171 square feet, it reaches a smaller group of buyers than a 6,000-square-foot house does. Its first $10 million asking price sat in public for every buyer to see, and the price came down from there.

Three Lots Bought in 2013 and 2014

Three of the five sales follow the same path. The owner bought an inland Winnetka property for $1.2 million to $1.5 million in 2013 or 2014, then built a new house or expanded the old one, and sold in 2026 for $5.5 million to $6.8 million.

  • On Laurel Avenue, the lot and the previous house cost $1.2 million in 2013, the new house went up in 2015, and it sold for $5.5 million this spring.
  • For the 2016 corner-lot house, the site cost just under $1.29 million in 2013, construction finished three years later, and the house sold for $6.8 million in September.
  • Hill Road last sold for $1.5 million in 2014, and after the expansion it sold for $5.6 million in February.

These figures leave out what each owner spent on construction, so none of this shows what the owners made. It does show where the market put its value this year. Both Hill Road and Laurel Avenue sit about a mile from Lake Michigan, Hill Road near the Indian Hill golf course. The Real Deal described the first two $5 million sales of the year as being "off the coveted Winnetka lakefront." For a buyer, that means a $5 million budget in Winnetka competes mostly for newer or rebuilt houses on interior streets. Lakefront homes trade in a different range.

The same private approach also worked below $5 million. The agent on the Laurel Avenue sale used the same process for 52 Locust Road, which sold April 30 for just over $3 million. She told The Real Deal that buyers will often pay more to get a home before it hits the market.

A Quieter Year on the Lakefront

Winnetka's top sale of 2026 was also private. The buyer at 715 Sheridan Road, a five-bedroom house on 0.82 acre with lakefront access, closed October 1 through a land trust. Chicago Star Media reported the price as $8.85 million, and The Real Deal reported $8.9 million. The Real Deal traced the site back to June 2000, when it sold for $2.9 million from the trust of Donald Grenesko, a former Chicago Cubs president. The current house was built that year and was never listed during the most recent ownership. The 2026 price was close to the Cook County Assessor's most recent valuation of a little over $9 million.

That figure is far below last year's peak. In 2025, two Winnetka lakefront homes sold above $30 million, 609 Sheridan Road at $32.5 million and 419 Sheridan Road at $31.3 million. The slowdown at the top was regional. Citing Crain's data, The Real Deal counted 62 Chicago-area sales of $4 million or more in the first half of 2026. That was down from 76 in the first half of 2025 but still the third-highest first half on record. By midyear, the most expensive sale in the metro area was $10.5 million. A year earlier, the midyear leader was a $12 million Winnetka sale.

Supply at this level stayed thin all the same. In February, The Real Deal found only one publicly listed resale in Winnetka, Kenilworth and Glencoe asking more than $5 million. The other four listings at that level in those three villages were spec homes not yet built. When so few finished homes are listed, more of them change hands before they ever appear online.

What Buyers and Sellers Should Take Into the Spring Market

For a buyer planning a spring move, the first serious opportunity may come long before April. Hill Road sold in February, and Laurel Avenue and 52 Locust Road sold in late April, all without public listings. A buyer who waits for spring listings may find that several of the houses they would have wanted have already sold. In practice, being ready means having financing in place, knowing which streets and house types you want, and working with someone who hears about homes before they are listed. I've written about how the Private Listing Network handles part of this. Much of the rest happens through personal contacts. You can see what is publicly available right now on our Winnetka homes for sale page.

For an owner of a finished, newer or thoroughly updated house, this year's sales show that a quiet private sale did not cost sellers money in 2026. In the most clear-cut case, it brought 32 percent more than the asking price. The Tudor on Sheridan shows the opposite risk. A public price far above what buyers will pay stays on record, and every later cut is public too. If you are deciding between a private sale and a full public launch, this earlier post covers the tradeoffs. A valuation based on this year's comparable sales is the right place to start.

FAQ

Were all of Winnetka's top 2026 sales off-market? No. The 140 Sheridan Road Tudor was publicly listed in early 2025 at around $10 million. It was reduced to $8.7 million and sold for $7.8 million. The other four sales above $5 million in this post closed privately.

What was the highest Winnetka home sale of 2026? 715 Sheridan Road closed October 1 for $8.85 million to $8.9 million, depending on which outlet reported it.

Did any of these homes sell above their asking price? 674 Hill Road sold for $5.6 million against a $4.25 million asking price in February, and the price included the furniture.

Most of Winnetka's top sales this year closed before a public listing. If you are deciding whether to buy or sell at this level privately or publicly, Mary Grant would be glad to go through this year's Winnetka sales with you. Schedule a private consultation.

STAY UP-TO-DATE ON THE LATEST REAL ESTATE TRENDS

RECENT BLOG POSTS

Work With Mary

Call Mary and learn what so many of her friends and colleagues already know: When it comes to helping you buy or sell your home, Mary will go above and beyond to get it done.